Your creator program, minus the manual work.

Find creators, manage relationships, and track results. All in one place.

How to Pay Influencers: 4 Payment Models and How to Run Payouts at Scale

Lizzie Davey
Content Writer
Nycole Hampton
Marketing Consultant and Adjuct Professor
Cheyanne Pettyjohn
Director of Influencer Marketing
Published date:
November 9, 2026

If I had to answer “how do you pay influencers?” in one sentence, I’d paraphrase veteran marketer Nycole Hampton and say: pay fairly and spend efficiently.

Easy to say, but harder to do when you’re juggling 40 creators across six countries, an inbox full of invoices with no VAT ID, and someone from finance asking (again) why there are 37 new suppliers this month.

And funnily enough, not one of those problems is about how much you’re paying.

You can negotiate the perfect rate, shake (virtual) hands, and still lose a creator because their invoice spent six weeks gathering dust in someone’s inbox 😬

So I find it helps to split paying influencers into two decisions:

  1. What you pay for. Flat fee, commission, a mix, or product. This decides whether a creator says yes in the first place.
  2. How the money reaches them. Contracts, invoices, currency, tax, and timing. This decides whether they come back.

I’ll walk you through both, starting with the different ways to pay (and when each one makes sense).

4 influencer payment models (and when to use each)

There are various ways to pay an influencer. The payment model you pick changes how much you spend upfront, who’s on the hook if a post flops, and whether a creator even replies to your email in the first place. Basically, there’s a lot riding on it.

Most brands end up using a mix, depending on the creator and the campaign.

Here’s a quick overview of each model before we dig in:

ModelWhat you pay forBest forWho carries the riskHow open creators are
Flat feeAgreed deliverablesWhen you need specific content by a specific dateYou (but the risk is lower than it seems when done right)Open
Commission onlyEach sale they driveCreators who already love your product and want ongoing earningsThe creatorCooling off fast
HybridA base fee plus commission for each sale/actionMost ongoing creator partnershipsSharedOpen, especially when it’s clearly explained
GiftingProduct (sometimes with agreed deliverables)Smaller creators, testing fitMostly you (product + shipping)Mixed


Whichever model you go with, a few extras can change the price. Usage rights, exclusivity, and whitelisting all sit on top of the base deal, so agree on them upfront rather than tacking them on after the content goes live.

Let’s go into each of these in more detail.

1: Flat fee (pay-per-post or retainer)

You agree on a set amount for set deliverables – say, two Reels and three Stories – and the creator gets paid whether the content sells 1,000 units or one.

That makes it the go-to model for awareness campaigns, launches, larger and managed creators (who rarely entertain anything else), and lower-margin products where revenue share just doesn’t make sense.

Flat fees also give you a lot of control, which makes them a lower-risk option than they might seem.

They’re ideal when:

  • You need specific content at a specific time, like a product launch, BFCM, or a seasonal campaign.
  • You love a creator’s style and want to reuse their content in your own marketing (just add usage rights to the deal).

If a creator consistently performs well for you, you can turn a flat fee into a three, six, nine, or 12-month retainer where they post about your brand regularly (often at a lower rate per post).

The trade-off is that you pay upfront, before you know how the content will perform. So make the deliverables in your agreement crystal clear, and base your fee on data rather than vibes.

A big follower count doesn’t mean much on its own. Those followers might not watch the creator’s videos, comment on their posts, or even live in a country you ship to.

So what do the pros look at? When we surveyed marketers on how they price creators, the top three data points they check are:

👉 Engagement rate (87.8%): is the audience actually paying attention?

👉 % of audience in your target location (65.9%): are they people you can sell to?

👉 Average views (63.4%): how many people will realistically see the content?

2: Commission-only (performance-based)

The creator earns a percentage of every sale they drive through their link or code. There’s zero upfront cost for you because you only pay out if they make a sale.

On paper, it’s the dream deal because there’s no risk of splashing out $2k for a post that gets three likes and no sales.

But commission-only isn’t always the bargain it looks like, for creators or for you.

For creators, the downside is obvious: they carry all the risk. For brands, it's a bit sneakier. When you haven’t paid anything upfront, it’s easy to put in less effort too. You have less skin in the game, which might mean you have less control over briefs or don’t feel like you can provide a ton of feedback.

In 2024, over 63% of marketers said creators were open to becoming affiliates. By 2025, that had dropped to 26%.

So what changed? Our survey of creators found that while 68% still accept commission, most do so with caveats:

👉 The rates aren’t worth it. 75% of creators said commissions aren’t attractive enough to make them want to post.

👉 There’s nothing to work toward. 6 in 10 marketers we polled run a single-tier affiliate program. If that starting rate isn’t great there’s no bump for selling more.

👉 They run out of product. 72% of creators say brands don’t regift often enough for them to keep promoting effectively. (Hard to rave about a face cream when the jar’s been empty since August.)

👉 They feel left to it. 70% of creators want marketers to be more involved in affiliate collabs.

So even creators who are happy to take on the risk often find commission-only hard to make work. The effort’s all on their side and their pay depends on things they can’t control, like how detailed the brief is, what day the post goes live, or what the algorithm’s in the mood for that week. It’s no wonder many creators would rather hold out for a guaranteed fee.

It also matters what you calculate commission on. There are two options:

  1. Gross revenue: the full order total, including shipping, tax, and the creator’s discount code.
  2. Net revenue: what you keep once you take those out.

Net is the fairer (and safer) option for your brand.

Pay 10% on the full $95 the customer spent and the creator gets $9.50. But $10 of that was shipping which you don’t keep. Pay on the $85 you actually earned and the commission is $8.50. A dollar doesn’t sound like much, but it adds up fast over a few hundred orders.

The good news is you don’t have to work any of this out by hand.

Modash automatically calculates commission on net revenue from your Shopify orders, after discounts and refunds and excluding shipping. You can also set different rates for first sales, repeat orders, and new customers. That’s handy if you want to reward creators more for bringing in brand-new customers than for selling to people who’d probably have bought anyway.

3: Hybrid (flat fee + commission)

If you sell online and want to tie spend to sales, this is the model I’d start with.

A smaller guaranteed fee covers the creator’s time, and commission rewards results. Even better, nobody carries all the risk.

You won’t be alone if you use this model: 52% of marketers we surveyed combine fixed fees with performance incentives. Creators like it too – 79% told us commission makes them more likely to work with a brand when it’s on top of a flat fee.

The secret ingredient is transparency. As Influencer Marketer Cheyanne Pettyjohn puts it:

If you do not explain your reasoning and show the data behind why a hybrid partnership works best for your company and the influencer, the latter will be left to assume you are trying to devalue their work and ultimately, pay them less.

avatar
Cheyanne PettyjohnDirector of Influencer Marketing

Hybrid deals also run smoother when creators can check their own numbers. In Modash, every creator gets their own payouts page showing what they’ve earned, what’s processing, what’s in their account, and when their next affiliate payout is due.

Here are two ways to make a hybrid deal work for both sides:

👉 Use a threshold. The creator earns commission only after their sales cover their flat fee. So if their rate is $300 per deliverable, the performance bonus only kicks in once they’ve driven $300 in sales.

👉 Offer a choice. If a creator is slightly over budget, give them two options: their usual rate with no bonus, or a slightly lower rate plus a bonus on every sale. It gives them a safety net, doesn’t undervalue their work, and is also a handy negotiation tactic.

4: Gifting and product-only deals

Gifting comes in two flavors:

👉 Product seeding: you send product with zero expectation that the creator will post about your brand.

👉 Barter deals: you agree on deliverables before you ship the product. You can also offer creators a discount code for their audience.

Most marketers prefer to have something agreed before they send out a gift. In our gifting survey, 54.8% said they prioritize barter deals. And the most common goal for gifting campaigns is brand awareness rather than straight-up sales.

Some brands take the barter idea a step further and invite creators to a launch event or cover their travel in exchange for content. Same rule applies: agree on the deliverables before anyone books a flight.

Gifting works best with smaller creators and it’s a low-cost way to see whether someone’s a good fit before you put cash on the table. Just don’t expect big creators who are already buried in PR boxes to post about a free moisturizer.

The tricky part is less about who to gift and more about the logistics. You chase addresses, ask for sizes and shades, check whether the parcel arrived, and then keep an eye out for whether they posted.

Multiply that by 50 creators, and your “low-effort” gifting campaign suddenly… isn’t so low-effort.

Modash takes most of that off your plate. You set a gift budget and choose which products creators can pick from. Each creator then gets their own discount code and free shipping code. You can see whether each gift has been ordered and fulfilled, and Modash automatically tracks what gets posted.

For the full playbook, see our guide on how to do influencer gifting step by step.

This works the same for comped events and trips, by the way. Instead of a product, you invite creators to a launch event or cover their travel in exchange for content.

Paying for extras like usage rights, exclusivity, and whitelisting

Regardless of the payment model you pick, there will be creators who charge extra for anything beyond a standard post. These add-ons can bump the price up quite a bit and include things like:

👉 Usage rights: this lets you reuse a creator’s content outside their own channels, like on your website, in emails, or as paid ads. Expect to pay anywhere from 25% to 100% of the creator’s base fee, usually for 1–3 months at a time. It’s worth it when your paid or ecommerce team has a clear plan for the content… but definitely check with them first.

👉 Exclusivity: this stops a creator from working with your competitors (or posting any sponsored content at all) for a set period.

A few days either side of your post is pretty normal and often free. Longer windows cost more, and full exclusivity (no sponsored posts at all) costs even more. This makes the most sense in niches where promoting two rivals back to back would look odd, like mattresses.

It’s harder to justify in fashion or beauty, where audiences expect creators to try lots of products.

👉 Whitelisting: this lets you run paid ads from the creator’s handle so they show up as coming from the creator rather than your brand. (On TikTok, the equivalent is Spark Ads.)

You’ll usually pay a usage fee on top of the content fee, often for 1–3 months, plus your ad spend. Some creators also ask for a cut of the ad budget or sales. It works best with creators you’ve already worked with and whose content you know performs well.

Top tip: Bundle these into your flat fee where you can (e.g. “Three Reels plus one month of digital usage rights”), rather than pricing each one separately.

How to choose the right way to pay an influencer

When you boil it down, payment models are really just an answer to the question: who carries the risk?

Which one you pick depends on the creator, the campaign, and how much risk you’re comfortable with. I’d work through it in this order…

Start with the campaign goal

Your goal won’t pick a model for you, but it tells you what you need to be sure of – and that decides how much of the deal should be fixed vs. tied to performance:

👉 Awareness or a launch: you need the content live on a set date, so lean on a fixed fee. If sales matter too, add a commission on top rather than making it the whole deal.

👉 Sales: you need to know what each creator actually drives, so a bigger share of the pay can be performance-based. Hybrid works for most creators, and commission-only can work for creators who’ve already proven they sell for you.

👉 Content you’ll reuse in ads: you need the rights to the content, so pay a fixed fee plus extra for usage rights, whatever else is in the deal.

Your product’s price matters too. It’s highly unlikely someone will buy a $1,500 mattress off the back of a single Reel. Sales for high-ticket products often come weeks later, through a different channel, so commission-only isn’t fair to the creator here. Keep a solid fixed fee in the mix.

Factor in the creator's size and bargaining power

It’s rare that a big-name creator with a full management team will accept a commission-only deal. They’ve probably got a ton of other offers on the table, so they can afford to say no (do you think Kim K is working on commission only?!).

You might find smaller creators are more open to gifting and commission, so think about the size of the creator you want to work with and what that might mean.

That said, if a creator pushes back, you don’t always have to raise the flat fee. Fernanda Marques, Influencer Marketing Manager at Cozy Cozy, sweetens the commission instead:

I typically offer them a higher commission bracket instead of increasing their fixed fee. This way, they still receive a guaranteed payment, but they also have the opportunity to earn significantly more if their content performs well.

avatar
Fernanda MarquesInfluencer Marketing Coordinator

Taking that a step further, give creators commission tiers to climb. Instead of one flat rate, the percentage goes up as they sell more. For example:

  • Tier 1: 8% commission on up to $1,000 in sales
  • Tier 2: 10% commission from $1,000 to $3,000
  • Tier 3: 12% commission on anything over $3,000

That works for commission-only and hybrid deals because there’s always a bigger payday to aim for.

It pays off too. In our affiliate marketing survey, brands with three or more commission tiers had an active affiliate rate closer to 50%, compared with 37% for brands on a single flat rate.

Run the numbers against your margins

Commission doesn’t automatically cost you less than paying a flat fee.

If a creator drives $50,000 in sales, a 15% commission-only model costs you $7,500 – fine. But if they drive $100,000, that’s $15,000, and a $10,000 flat fee would’ve been a better deal.

So model a few scenarios first. Then set your commission rate by working backward from your margin:

  1. Start with your profit on a typical sale before commission.
  2. Decide how much of that you’re willing to give up to win a customer.
  3. Set your top rate there.

For example, if you keep 30% profit on a sale, a top rate of around 15% leaves you half of it and still gives the creator a decent cut. If your margins are tighter, start lower or pay a flat fee instead.

Let the model change as the relationship grows

The payment model you start with doesn’t have to be the one you stick with forever. Think of it more like dating than marriage – start small and see how it goes 💍

A pretty natural path looks like this:

  1. Gift first to see if the creator likes your product (and whether they post about it).
  2. Move to hybrid once they’ve shown they can sell some units.
  3. Lock in a long-term partnership with a retainer for your star performers.

Starting simple also makes it easier to spot who’s worth investing in. Gifting and early hybrid deals show you who’s converting, and with which products or links, so you can scale up with the creators who’ve proven themselves.

Once you reach the long-term stage, it’s usually a win for the creator too. A retainer gives them steady, predictable income, and over time a long-term partnership tends to earn them more than a string of one-off deals. It helps to show them that upfront with real numbers from your program so they can see what’s in it for them.

Now that you know which model works best for you, let’s look at what the payment process looks like in practice.

How to pay influencers in 7 steps

When you’re working with five creators, a spreadsheet and a few bank transfers will do the job. But at 50? That’s a way bigger ask.

Here’s how to keep things running smoothly as you scale, from the first agreement to the money landing in a creator’s account.

Step 1: Put the payment terms in writing

I get it. You’ve found a creator you love, they’ve said yes, and the last thing you want to do is kill the vibe with paperwork.

But sorting the details later is how a creator ends up waiting three months for a payment they thought was due the day they posted 🙃

So get it all down in writing before anyone hits record.

At minimum, your agreement should cover:

  • Amount and currency
  • Deliverables and deadlines
  • What triggers payment (posting, approval, or a set date)
  • Payment terms (e.g. net-30)
  • Usage rights and exclusivity

🤓 Grab our free influencer contract template to get started.

Even with a solid contract, it’s easy to lose track of what you agreed… especially if you have the contract in a Drive folder, the invoice in your inbox, and the payment in another tool altogether.

Modash keeps it all in one place. You create each payment against the signed contract, with the agreed amount, currency, and deliverables attached. That way you, the creator, and your finance team are all on the same page.

Step 2: Collect invoices without the back-and-forth

Ah, invoices. Everyone loves getting paid, but nobody loves invoicing.

And they tend to get bounced back for the same boring reasons every time: No VAT ID, or no address, or they’re in the wrong currency, or your company name is spelled in a litany of weird and wonderful ways.

Send a short checklist upfront to save you a fair chunk of that pain. Something like:

  • Their full legal or business name and address
  • Their VAT ID or tax number (if they’re registered)
  • A unique invoice number and date
  • Your company name and billing address (spelled correctly pls)
  • What the invoice is for (campaign name and deliverables)
  • The agreed amount and currency
  • Their payment details
  • A PO number if your finance team uses them
  • Where to send it

Fair warning: you’ll probably still play a bit of invoice ping-pong now and then.

Or you could just… not. With Modash payments, the creator gets an email link, then either uploads their own invoice or lets Modash generate a compliant one from their saved details. And if something’s missing, Modash does the chasing – not you 💅

Step 3: Approve and confirm the payment

Finance will want to know who signed off on what. (They always do. It’s basically their love language.)

So decide who approves creator payments, plus have a backup for when that person’s sunning themselves in Mallorca ☀️

In Modash, you can save payments as drafts that a teammate has to confirm before anything goes out. Modash also logs who approved what and when, so your audit trail stays nice and tidy. And you can label payments by campaign, market, or whatever else floats your boat, which makes filtering them later a breeze.

Step 4: Choose how the money gets to the creator

You can pay creators however you like – bank transfer, PayPal, a big sack of gold coins – but most brands stick to one of these:

MethodsProsConsFees for creators
PayPalFamiliar, fast, easy to set upHigher fees, accounts can get frozenReceiving and conversion fees
Bank transferReliable, lower fees on big payoutsSlower, and you need their bank detailsInternational wire and intermediary fees
StripeFlexible, easy to automateTakes a bit of setupFees depend on setup
In-platformAutomates payouts, often handles taxPlatform costDepends on the platform

Modash pays creators straight into their bank account in their local currency, with no fees on their end. You top up one balance instead of juggling hundreds of separate transfers. Payouts are free up to $10k a year, then there’s a 5% fee on creator payouts. We never take a cut of creator revenue.

Step 5: Handle tax and compliance for international creators

⚠️ Disclaimer: I’m a writer, not an accountant, so please don’t take this as legal advice and do have a chat with your accountant.

With that out of the way, here are the usual suspects you’ll want to look out for depending on where you’re based:

  • US brands: a W-9 from US creators, and usually a W-8BEN from creators based abroad.
  • EU creators: a VAT ID on the invoice if they’re VAT-registered.
  • Everywhere else: local rules vary a lot, so double-check before you pay.

If you’d rather not become an accidental expert in international tax law (same), Modash acts as your single payment and compliance vendor.

Finance pays one invoice and gets a monthly report of every payment, instead of wading through hundreds of individual creator invoices. They might even send you a thank-you note 🤭

Step 6: Keep creators in the loop on payment status

Creators remember the brands that paid them on time… but they really remember the ones that didn’t (and not in a good way).

The easiest win here is to have a predictable schedule. Robert Polonski, Media Partnerships Manager at Deeper, swears by locked payment dates:

If we have a locked date by when each month’s commission must be paid out, it makes it easier for both parties. The creator has less stuff to worry about and we have a stable movement of budget.

avatar
Robert PolonskiMedia Partnerships Coordinator, Deeper

In Modash, every payment has its own timeline showing each status change with a timestamp – created, confirmed, invoice submitted, approved, sent. Creators can also check their own Payouts page.

Step 7: Pay out commissions on hybrid and affiliate deals

If you’re running a commission model you’ll have a few extra curveballs thrown into the mix, so it’s a good idea to have three ground rules:

  • A minimum payout threshold so you’re not sending tiny $2.40 transfers every week.
  • A hold period that covers your return window, so you’re not paying out on sales that boomerang back.
  • A fixed payout schedule. Monthly is the norm.

With Modash’s affiliate payouts, you set your own hold period, and if an order gets refunded in Shopify before the commission is paid out, Modash automatically reduces or removes it. Set your hold period to cover your return window and you’re covered for most returns.

🤓 For more on thresholds, hold periods, and payout schedules, take a look at our full guide to affiliate payouts.

Pay fairly, then pay on time

So, to recap: paying influencers comes down to two things.

First, offer a deal creators will actually say yes to. For most brands, that’s a hybrid model. Second, get the money to them on time with no nasty surprises.

If the payment admin is slowly eating your week (and your will to live), Modash can take it off your plate. You can pay flat fees and affiliate commissions to creators in 180+ countries, all from one place.

But payments are just the tip of the iceberg. With Modash, you can also:

👉 Find creators who fit your brand, and check their audience data before you reach out

👉 Reach out and stay organized with every creator conversation in one inbox

👉 Send products and discount codes straight from your Shopify store

👉 Track every post and sale automatically so you know exactly who’s driving results

So instead of juggling spreadsheets, email threads, and three different payment tools (🙃), your entire creator program lives in one place.

If you’re ready to wave goodbye to invoice ping-pong for good, try Modash free for 14 days.

FAQ

How do you pay influencers in other countries?

Bank transfer, PayPal, or a payment platform. The tricky bits are currency conversion, transfer fees, and tax forms. A platform like Modash pays creators in their local currency across 180+ countries, so you don’t have to manage each transfer.

Should you pay influencers before or after they post?

Paying after the content goes live (or gets approved) on net-30 terms is a common setup. For bigger deals, some brands split it – part upfront, part after posting – which helps build trust with the creator.

Is gifting enough to pay an influencer?

Sometimes, usually with smaller creators who truly love your product. For agreed deliverables from established creators, expect to pay cash too.

What’s a fair commission rate for influencers?

Most brands offer 10%–14%, rising to 15% or more for higher-margin products or top performers. To find your own rate, work backward from your margin. If you keep 30% profit on a sale, a top rate of around 15% leaves you half of it. If your margins are tighter, start lower or pay a flat fee instead.

Do influencers need to send an invoice?

Yes, for your accounting and tax records. Tools like Modash can automatically generate compliant invoices for creators.

How long should creators wait to be paid?

Net-30 is standard for flat fees. For commissions, go for monthly payouts after a hold period that covers your return window.

Can you pay influencers through PayPal?

Yes, and lots of brands do. Just be aware that fees and currency conversion can eat into what the creator receives, especially for international payments.

Your creator program, minus the manual work.

Find creators, manage relationships, and track results. All in one place.

Our expert contributors